(12-04-2022, 07:17 PM)burger Wrote: I hate to admit this, but Hurley is a far better coach than Haase. ASU ran *actual plays* on offense. We can only dream of that level of offensive competence under Haase.
Also, if the Stanford continues to not take transfers, and every other P-12 team gets to reload every single season like ASU did, I'm going to give up watching college sports. It's like if your favorite pro football team decided to sign no free agents--good luck winning more than a few games the next season.
Stanford will miss you as a fan then because there is no way Stanford will take transfers in numbers to meet the needs or desires of multiple coaches in this new transfer portal world.
Many schools have as many incoming transfers each fall as they have incoming freshmen. In a number of those universities transfer students actually have inferior high school academic resumes compared to their incoming freshmen peers. So it is not difficult at all for schools that admit thousands of transfers to admit a couple of dozen football players and perhaps a few dozen athletes in other sports.
The 2021-2022 Common Data Set reveals Stanford admitted 55 students. Not 55 students for sports, 55 total.
For 2020-2021 the number was 86. And those are big numbers presumably aided by COVID-19 enrollment disruptions.
For 2019-2020 it was 24.
For 2018-2019 it was 27.
For 2017-2018 it was 31.
For 2016-2017 it was 42.
I just can't imagine Stanford University would double that number just to admit replacement athletes for sports teams.
And then there is the admissions complexity. At a lot of schools the coach can shop the portal and more or less offer a spot to an athlete in real time. At Stanford the athlete in the portal would still need to complete some form of application. That real admissions process can't be appealing for those seeking to leave a program ASAP. I would think most want to get real offers in mere weeks and then take an offer as quickly as possible.
Just for comparison for 2021-2022
UofA - 5,907 admitted transfer applicants
Colorado - 3,135 admitted transfer applicants
USC - 2,208 admitted transfer applicants
For schools admitting thousands of students, it really is not a big deal to fast track admissions for a few dozen athletes.
FWIW - For hoops I don't think the transfer portal is quite as powerful for men's hoops as it has been in football. Even first year college basketball athletes can opt for the draft, or pursue international opportunities. And the prevalence of one and done types gives those that stay in a program for a couple of years a pretty decent shot at meaningful playing time. There are quite a few programs that routinely get into the second or third round of the NCAA tournament with scrappy players that execute a system with incredible precision.
The men's hoops team almost can't get better recruits than Haase has been getting over the last few cycles. Muir, who came in with high profile hoops experience, should be able to assess the situation on the court.
I really hoped the trends were obvious over the last 3 seasons, but perhaps it will take an absolute dumpster fire of a season to clarify the situation for Muir.