[teejers1]

Actually, the point was the comparison to Posey with other catchers, who typically suffer far more day-to-day wear and tear on the body. 

Posey was a catcher roughly 75% of the time (76% to be more precise), based on ABs.  The rhetorical question is does that same percentageapply to the other catchers you compared him to?  I suspect not (but don't know).

[teejers1]

Actually, the point was the comparison to Posey with other catchers, who typically suffer far more day-to-day wear and tear on the body. 

Posey was a catcher roughly 75% of the time (76% to be more precise), based on ABs.  The rhetorical question is does that same percentageapply to the other catchers you compared him to?  I suspect not (but don't know).