[Mick]

I haven't seen either of them play -- is Wisely a ML shortstop?  Or are the Giants just waiting for Luciano to figure it out?

On very little data, Wisely appears to be better at SS (+1Rtot) than CF (0Rtot) and 2B (-1Rtot). He's played 26 games at shortstop, only one error and 15 DPs. His range factor per 9 innings is 4.76 vs. the MLB average of 3.88, so he's getting to almost one more full chance per game than the typical shortstop. Those are some excellent numbers. And he's hitting .278/.313/.421/.734. That's a 113 OPS+. I'd say he's doing great.

[Mick]

I haven't seen either of them play -- is Wisely a ML shortstop?  Or are the Giants just waiting for Luciano to figure it out?

On very little data, Wisely appears to be better at SS (+1Rtot) than CF (0Rtot) and 2B (-1Rtot). He's played 26 games at shortstop, only one error and 15 DPs. His range factor per 9 innings is 4.76 vs. the MLB average of 3.88, so he's getting to almost one more full chance per game than the typical shortstop. Those are some excellent numbers. And he's hitting .278/.313/.421/.734. That's a 113 OPS+. I'd say he's doing great.