Mel Stottlemyre, yes. 12-20 for the 1966 Yankees, led the league in losses, also led the league in losses six years later when he went 16-18. But he won 20 games three other years, finishing 164-139. So the man could pitch.
Here's the rest of the pitchers who both lost 20 games and made the All-Star team that year...and whether they actually pitched in the game. Raffensberger actually won the All Star game in 1944:
Pitcher Year Team W–L Pitched in All-Star Game?
Hugh Mulcahy 1940 Phillies 13–22 No
Eddie Smith 1942 White Sox 7–20 No
Ken Raffensberger 1944 Phillies 13–20 Yes
Bob Rush 1950 Cubs 13–20 No
Sam Jones 1955 Cubs 14–20 Yes
Turk Farrell 1962 Houston Colt .45s 10–20 Yes
Mel Stottlemyre 1966 Yankees 12–20 Yes
Steve Rogers 1974 Expos 15–22 No
Here's the rest of the pitchers who both lost 20 games and made the All-Star team that year...and whether they actually pitched in the game. Raffensberger actually won the All Star game in 1944:
Pitcher Year Team W–L Pitched in All-Star Game?
Hugh Mulcahy 1940 Phillies 13–22 No
Eddie Smith 1942 White Sox 7–20 No
Ken Raffensberger 1944 Phillies 13–20 Yes
Bob Rush 1950 Cubs 13–20 No
Sam Jones 1955 Cubs 14–20 Yes
Turk Farrell 1962 Houston Colt .45s 10–20 Yes
Mel Stottlemyre 1966 Yankees 12–20 Yes
Steve Rogers 1974 Expos 15–22 No
Audaces fortuna iuvat
