[82lsju]

QB: Costello or Mills

https://gostanford.com/documents/2019/10...f?id=17486


from the QB thread posted by Cardinal Sagehen

Shaw on personnel:

K.J. Costello somewhere between questionable and doubtful. Will try to throw today.

Devery Hamilton will he down again this week and we’ll see what’s possible next week.

https://twitter.com/StanfordFball/status...3pid256969

[82lsju]

QB: Costello or Mills

https://gostanford.com/documents/2019/10...f?id=17486


from the QB thread posted by Cardinal Sagehen

Shaw on personnel:

K.J. Costello somewhere between questionable and doubtful. Will try to throw today.

Devery Hamilton will he down again this week and we’ll see what’s possible next week.

https://twitter.com/StanfordFball/status...3pid256969

[Spiny_Norman]

More injury news.

[twitter]https://twitter.com/StanfordRivals/status/1179109441058197504[/twitter]

[Spiny_Norman]

More injury news.

[twitter]https://twitter.com/StanfordRivals/status/1179109441058197504[/twitter]

[CardinalSagehen]

It’s not going to happen for many different reasons, but just hypothetically, could a “retired” Masters student with a year of eligibility remaining return to play mid-season? (e.g., Nick Wilson) Or is there some sort of filing deadline?

I remember the Utah running back that had quit mid-season and came back later that season, but I’ve never heard of a retired 5th year player coming back.

[CardinalSagehen]

It’s not going to happen for many different reasons, but just hypothetically, could a “retired” Masters student with a year of eligibility remaining return to play mid-season? (e.g., Nick Wilson) Or is there some sort of filing deadline?

I remember the Utah running back that had quit mid-season and came back later that season, but I’ve never heard of a retired 5th year player coming back.

[BobK]

I would strongly guess yes. Thinking it happened mbb maybe
But is Wilson physically able?

I like your thought

[BobK]

I would strongly guess yes. Thinking it happened mbb maybe
But is Wilson physically able?

I like your thought

[Spiny_Norman]

My $0.02. If needed, Tucker Fisk could slide over and cover a tackle position.

[Spiny_Norman]

My $0.02. If needed, Tucker Fisk could slide over and cover a tackle position.

[Phogge]

Spoke with a former close to the program guy tonight and he is not one of the usual suspects. Can’t believe that the program has gone into “hibernation.” Blames Muir for not lighting a fire under Shaw who has grown stale. The grumbling is spreading.

[Phogge]

Spoke with a former close to the program guy tonight and he is not one of the usual suspects. Can’t believe that the program has gone into “hibernation.” Blames Muir for not lighting a fire under Shaw who has grown stale. The grumbling is spreading.

[winflop]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

[winflop]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

[djones]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Like a lot of linemen following retirement...Nick has lost at least 50 lbs.

[djones]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Like a lot of linemen following retirement...Nick has lost at least 50 lbs.

[Phogge]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Somebody has to. Recruiting failures have torpedoed the OL. So if not lighting a fire what is the AD's job? Perhaps socializing with the elite in CTG?

[Phogge]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Somebody has to. Recruiting failures have torpedoed the OL. So if not lighting a fire what is the AD's job? Perhaps socializing with the elite in CTG?

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

QB: Costello or Mills

https://gostanford.com/documents/2019/10...f?id=17486


from the QB thread posted by Cardinal Sagehen

Shaw on personnel:

K.J. Costello somewhere between questionable and doubtful. Will try to throw today.

Devery Hamilton will he down again this week and we’ll see what’s possible next week.

https://twitter.com/StanfordFball/status...3pid256969

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

QB: Costello or Mills

https://gostanford.com/documents/2019/10...f?id=17486


from the QB thread posted by Cardinal Sagehen

Shaw on personnel:

K.J. Costello somewhere between questionable and doubtful. Will try to throw today.

Devery Hamilton will he down again this week and we’ll see what’s possible next week.

https://twitter.com/StanfordFball/status...3pid256969

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

[murky]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Like a lot of linemen following retirement...Nick has lost at least 50 lbs.

Good for him.  Jumbo athlete appetite and civilian lifestyle could be a dangerous combination.

[murky]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Like a lot of linemen following retirement...Nick has lost at least 50 lbs.

Good for him.  Jumbo athlete appetite and civilian lifestyle could be a dangerous combination.

[82lsju]

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

see more in this thread, the table in the first post has some of what you are looking for

https://thecardboard.org/board/showthread.php?tid=17122

[82lsju]

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

see more in this thread, the table in the first post has some of what you are looking for

https://thecardboard.org/board/showthread.php?tid=17122

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

see more in this thread, the table in the first post has some of what you are looking for

https://thecardboard.org/board/showthread.php?tid=17122

Very helpful information, thank you.

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

On the depth chart I counted eleven freshman. Does this mean the other ten or so freshmen on the roster will have this season declared for them a redshirt year ?

see more in this thread, the table in the first post has some of what you are looking for

https://thecardboard.org/board/showthread.php?tid=17122

Very helpful information, thank you.

[winflop]

Per Troy Clardy, KJ is out. Mills will start.

[winflop]

Per Troy Clardy, KJ is out. Mills will start.

[OutsiderFan]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

[OutsiderFan]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

[82lsju]

Per Troy Clardy, KJ is out. Mills will start.

Injury update: After practice Wednesday night, David Shaw, said quarterback K.J. Costello would miss his second consecutive game

tackle Devery Hamilton and cornerback Ethan Bonner are also out, while guard Dylan Powell is likely sidelined for the season. safety Stuart Head received his first playing time of the season against OSU and should be available, while cornerback Treyjohn Butler is questionable.

https://gostanford.com/news/2019/10/2/fo...ngton.aspx

[82lsju]

Per Troy Clardy, KJ is out. Mills will start.

Injury update: After practice Wednesday night, David Shaw, said quarterback K.J. Costello would miss his second consecutive game

tackle Devery Hamilton and cornerback Ethan Bonner are also out, while guard Dylan Powell is likely sidelined for the season. safety Stuart Head received his first playing time of the season against OSU and should be available, while cornerback Treyjohn Butler is questionable.

https://gostanford.com/news/2019/10/2/fo...ngton.aspx

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

Without knowing the extent of KJ's thumb injury it is hard to predict if or when he will again be Stanford's starting QB.
Compared to KJ, I think Mills has more of a fundamentally sound throwing motion and quicker release. Also, his passes seem to be tight spirals with excellent accuracy. It seems as though Mills mobility is about the same as KJ's, but I would like to see more Mills game time to better make this comparison.
On the plus side for KJ he plays with great passion, which is significant.

[SF_Cardinal_Fan]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

Without knowing the extent of KJ's thumb injury it is hard to predict if or when he will again be Stanford's starting QB.
Compared to KJ, I think Mills has more of a fundamentally sound throwing motion and quicker release. Also, his passes seem to be tight spirals with excellent accuracy. It seems as though Mills mobility is about the same as KJ's, but I would like to see more Mills game time to better make this comparison.
On the plus side for KJ he plays with great passion, which is significant.

[donkey687]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

Hit open receivers regularly and guide the offense to more than 28 points to beat UW! He can do it.

[donkey687]

What must Mills do Saturday to justify keeping the QB job even when Costello is healthy?

My opinion is Costello is good, but Mills is better. Discuss.

Hit open receivers regularly and guide the offense to more than 28 points to beat UW! He can do it.

[winflop]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Somebody has to. Recruiting failures have torpedoed the OL. So if not lighting a fire what is the AD's job? Perhaps socializing with the elite in CTG?

My point is that nobody should have to light a fire under Shaw after this season - it's that bad already. If Muir has to do it, then Shaw has a bigger blinders-on problem that we thought.

[winflop]

My understanding was that Wilson felt the program didn't support him and the decision to leave was his. If true, I doubt he'd come back even if he could physically.

Muir shouldn't have to light a fire under Shaw after this season. If Muir does, that's a serious problem.

Somebody has to. Recruiting failures have torpedoed the OL. So if not lighting a fire what is the AD's job? Perhaps socializing with the elite in CTG?

My point is that nobody should have to light a fire under Shaw after this season - it's that bad already. If Muir has to do it, then Shaw has a bigger blinders-on problem that we thought.

[Phogge]

Shaw must have a very low heart rate. I would love to see him get in somebody's face just one time. It could be a player, coach, Dolly, popcorn vendor, three year old Husky fan, a 102 year old grandmother, just anybody. He needs a small shot of Durkinism. The most passionless coach or manager since Clancy Sheehan in 1960. At least Clancy had an excuse. He had a daily hangover after drinking all night with Horace Stoneham and Hank Sauer.

[Phogge]

Shaw must have a very low heart rate. I would love to see him get in somebody's face just one time. It could be a player, coach, Dolly, popcorn vendor, three year old Husky fan, a 102 year old grandmother, just anybody. He needs a small shot of Durkinism. The most passionless coach or manager since Clancy Sheehan in 1960. At least Clancy had an excuse. He had a daily hangover after drinking all night with Horace Stoneham and Hank Sauer.