[oman]

Of course the rest of the situation is relevant.  But I can't conceive of any possible hypothetical scenario in which Incognito's voicemail isn't harassment (again, unless he was obviously kidding, which the rest of the case clearly indicates he wasn't).  Can you?

This is already dragged out too long so I will just say that you make some good points but I want to clarify a couple of things.

1) I'm a bit taken aback by your comment that I am blaming the victim.  This isn't akin to me blaming a rape victim.  This is a harassment situation where the conduct of the recipient is going to be very relevant. 

2) Yeah, I could imagine a case where these guys are talking very ugly trash to each other and leaving idiotic messages on each others phones. 

[oman]

Of course the rest of the situation is relevant.  But I can't conceive of any possible hypothetical scenario in which Incognito's voicemail isn't harassment (again, unless he was obviously kidding, which the rest of the case clearly indicates he wasn't).  Can you?

This is already dragged out too long so I will just say that you make some good points but I want to clarify a couple of things.

1) I'm a bit taken aback by your comment that I am blaming the victim.  This isn't akin to me blaming a rape victim.  This is a harassment situation where the conduct of the recipient is going to be very relevant. 

2) Yeah, I could imagine a case where these guys are talking very ugly trash to each other and leaving idiotic messages on each others phones.